What to Say When Your Child Is Scared: Preschool Activities and a Family Prayer for Faith Over Fear | 92
Your child comes to you and says they’re scared. Maybe it’s the dark, maybe it’s a dog down the street, maybe it’s a sound in the hallway you can’t even hear. And most of us say the first thing that comes out: “There’s nothing to be scared of.”
This week, you can give your child something better than that sentence. You can show them that being scared isn’t the problem, and that there’s somewhere to take it.
Our one sentence for the whole month is: “When your faith covers your fear, God is right there with you in it.” Everything below points to that.
How I failed the first time
My five-year-old is terrified of roller coasters. He wasn’t always. He actually loved them. This kid rode some pretty big rides at Universal without blinking. But there was one ride, one time, a roller coaster none of us had ever been on before, and after that he was done. Any hill, no matter how small, was a no.
We recently took our kids to Peppa Pig Park here in Florida. The Daddy Pig coaster doesn’t even have a drop. It just goes around in a circle. Finnegan, who was two, was ecstatic. Maximus, who was four and had ridden that ride countless times, lost his mind walking toward the line.
We told him he’d done it before. We tried to get him to just watch it. There was no reasoning with him. I get it. Absolutely do. I was the same way as a kid.
Mike took him to watch while Finnegan and I rode. If I’m being honest, I was frustrated. It was a roller coaster built for toddlers, and he acted like I was trying to get him on the Incredible Hulk at Islands of Adventure, which I would never, ever ride.
But when I got to him and saw his sweet little face, calm, with red eyes from crying, every bit of that frustration left my body. Finnegan ran off to Mike, and I knelt down next to Max and asked if he needed a hug.
What I said instead
Instead of trying to get him to explain his fear, I held him and said, “Thank you for being brave enough to tell us you didn’t want to do something.”
At the end of the day, I don’t need him to ride a kiddie roller coaster. I need him to know he can trust me with his fear, and that I’ll help him through it, not force him to stop being scared.
But what about when he’s older and I’m not there? When the roller coaster isn’t a ride you get to choose? When it’s a huge life problem that needs something bigger than a hug from mom?
That’s the kind of fear only God can handle.
Jesus knew where to take it
In Mark 14, it’s the night before the cross, and Jesus goes to a garden called Gethsemane to pray. Mark tells us He was deeply distressed and troubled. He tells His closest friends His soul is overwhelmed, to the point of death.
He doesn’t pretend it’s fine. Instead, he falls to the ground and prays. He calls God “Abba, Father,” a close, family word, and He’s honest about the thing He doesn’t want to do: “Take this cup from me.”
God didn’t take the cross away. But Luke tells us an angel came and strengthened Him (Luke 22:43). The hard thing didn’t disappear. Jesus just wasn’t alone in it.
Hebrews 4:15 tells us Jesus knows what it’s like to be human in every way, yet He never sinned. So feeling scared isn’t a sin, and it isn’t a lack of faith. Jesus felt it too. What made the difference was where He took it.
That’s the whole lesson for your kids: being scared isn’t the problem. Knowing where to take it is.
Why this works for little kids
Little kids don’t separate what they feel from what’s true. When they say the dark is scary, to them the dark is scary. If we argue with the feeling, they learn to stop telling us. If we give them somewhere to take it, they learn what to do with it.
And they learn it best with their hands. So here are three short lessons, about ten to fifteen minutes each. Spread them across your week however it works for your family, and sing the theme song every time.
Lesson 1: Teach It
Sit down with your child somewhere comfy. They don’t need to give you 100% of their attention. They can play with toys or draw. Just make sure they hear this:
Say: “Feeling scared isn’t bad. Jesus felt scared too, but He knew where to take it.”
Ask: “Where did Jesus take His fear?”
Hopefully your child says God. If not, that’s fine. Tell them: “God. Jesus prayed to God about being scared.” You’re not quizzing them. You’re planting it.
Fear and Faith Hands
- Make a fist, and ask your child to make one too. Say: “This is your fear.”
- Hold up your other hand, open. Say: “This is faith.”
- Cover the fist with your open hand. Say: “When you are scared, you can tell God, and the faith you have will cover your fear. Having faith doesn’t mean our fear always goes away, but we are never alone.”
- Ask: “Who covers our fear?” Hopefully they say God. If not, say it together.
You lead it this week. By the end of the month, the goal is for your child to do the whole thing on their own.
The song: “My Faith Is”
My faith is (hand on heart)
Bigger (arms out wide)
Than my fear (hands on cheeks, scared face)
Bigger (arms wide again)
Than my fear (hands on cheeks)
I’m not scared. No, no. (wag fingers no)
The second verse is the same, but it ends on “Hallelujah” with arms up high, waving side to side. Watch the motions here: https://www.godhomeschool.com/myfaithis/
Lesson 2: Act It Out with the Brave Box

This learning game helps your child see where they can take their fear.
You’ll need: a box with a lid, paper and crayons. Many families already have these at home. If you don’t, feel free to adapt for your family. A shoebox, a gift bag or even a folded piece of paper works.
- Invite your child to draw something that feels scary to them, or to tell you about it while you draw. They choose what to share.
- Put the drawing in the box and close the lid. Give it a shake, like the scary thing is rattling around inside. Ask: “What should we do with this?” Say: “Let’s give it to God.”
- Open the box together and toss the drawing up toward the ceiling. Grab it fast and tuck it into your shirt or behind your back, somewhere your child can’t see where it went. Say: “It’s in God’s hands now. We might still feel scared, but God is always with us.”
- Later, throw the drawing away when your child isn’t looking, or keep it hidden if you love it. If your child wants to keep their drawing, that’s okay too. Say: “Remember, any time you’re scared, you can give it to God again.”
Ask: “Who has our scary thing now?”
The scary thing went up, and it didn’t come back down. It gives them a picture of fear having somewhere to go.
Lesson 3: Pray It with a family prayer
Help your child write their very own prayer about being scared, in their own words. First, teach them BAM:
- B: Be Honest. Tell God exactly what’s scaring you.
- A: Ask. Ask God to help you not be afraid.
- M: Magnify. Thank God for being bigger than your fear, and for being right there with you.
Then fill in the blanks together:
God, I’m scared of ________.
Please help me ________.
Thank you for ________.
Amen.
From a four-year-old, it might sound like this: “God, I’m scared of the big slide. Please help me not be scared. Thank you for being bigger than my scared, and for being right here with me. Amen.”
Use your child’s words, not yours. If they say the closet is creepy, write creepy. A prayer they wrote themselves means more to them than a better-sounding one you wrote for them.
Pray it together at bedtime, out loud, at their volume. Then tape it to their bed frame so they’ll see it again.
If it doesn’t go as planned
If your child doesn’t want to draw, doesn’t answer the questions, or you miss a lesson entirely, that’s okay. Nothing here needs to be perfect. Your child leads. You invite and never force, especially when the topic is something scary. Even one of these lessons plants something.
Your child might not remember the box. But they might remember that the scary thing went up to God and didn’t come back down. That’s a picture they can pull up years from now, when the scary thing is a lot bigger than the dark.
Get the free Faith Over Fear lesson plan
The whole month is on one printable: the song lyrics and motions, all three family prayer frames, and every line you say to your child marked so you can glance at it in the middle of an activity.
Get it by joining the free God Homeschool Facebook group at https://www.godhomeschool.com/facebookgroup/, or by signing up for the newsletter at https://www.godhomeschool.com/newsletter/. And if you try the Brave Box, share what your kids draw in the group!
🎧 Listen to the full episode: https://www.godhomeschool.com/listen/
